Should I sift the flour when making bread?


I grew up always sifting flour before measuring when baking anything. Is it necessary when baking bread?

(Disclaimer: This discussion applies only to bread, not pastries, cakes, or cookies)

Two reasons you don't have to sift flour when making bread:

  1. According to Bon Appetit: "Modern techniques have improved significantly...most commercial flour is refined and clump-free, meaning there's no real need to sift it."
  2. Weighing is the new "measuring" method for bread (for my American readers). If you want to be more than a one-trick pony when it comes to baking bread, a digital scale is essential.

🤔 It just occurred to me that bread machines are often sold with measuring cups. What a mistake! If I sold those machines, I would include a free digital scale. I bet there wouldn't be near as many bread machines in garage sales. (I would also remove the "bake" button, but that's a topic for another day.)

One caveat: If you happen to purchase a bag of flour with lumps, go ahead and sift it (place a big sifter over a big bowl and stir with a whisk until all the flour goes into the bowl.) You still need to weigh it when you make bread, but it will mix easier when added to your bread machine.

Find links to my favorite digital scales in my Amazon Store. Unfortunately, I can't make it link through email, so type Amazon Store SaladinaJar into the search box.

See this post if you have more questions about measuring flour for bread,


If you want to practice weighing flour, try my recipe for Easy Enough Bread Machine Pretzel Dough for Buns or Rolls.

What readers say about Bread Machine Pretzel Buns:

Saying good-bye to my rusty old sifter,

Paula

p.s Thank you for sharing this email and recipe with your favorite bread-baking friends.

Salad in a Jar

Check out my previous newsletters below. If you haven't already, sign up for my newsletter!

Read more from Salad in a Jar
loaf caving in on the right side

Hi Friends, I hope you had a wonderful holiday season and are ready to get serious about baking fantastic bread. Quick clarification before we dive into this tricky topic:I’m not talking about loaves that sink on top—that’s usually overproofing. Check out the right side where the loaf is starting to cave in. I’m talking about loaves that look fine out of the oven, then cave inward on the side as they cool. That kind of collapse almost always points to a structure problem, not fermentation....

Easy bread machine cinnamon roll, frosted and ready to serve.

No matter where you are on your bread-making journey, I’ve got a Christmas-morning-worthy recipe for you — whether you’re baking for brunch, snacks, or something sweet to nibble while the coffee brews. Beginning Bread Bakers Start Here: Easy Bread Machine Cinnamon Rolls with a Secret Ingredients A great make-ahead option for beginners. Mix the dough the day before and bake in the morning. The secret? A tiny pinch of cloves (optional) that adds warmth without shouting. Click to see the recipe...

slice and bake coconut shortbread

Hi Friends, My mom was ahead of her time when she engaged in a little DIY aversion therapy with my pre-teen self. One day, I asked if I could make a full batch of Butterscotch Refrigerator Cookies purely to eat the dough. After a moment of hesitation, she said, “Go right ahead.” So I did… and I ate most of it right on the spot. Not surprisingly, I never made that recipe again. These days I stick to cookies I actually enjoy baked—one at a time, mostly 😉—like my Slice and Bake Coconut...