Should I sift the flour when making bread?


I grew up always sifting flour before measuring when baking anything. Is it necessary when baking bread?

(Disclaimer: This discussion applies only to bread, not pastries, cakes, or cookies)

Two reasons you don't have to sift flour when making bread:

  1. According to Bon Appetit: "Modern techniques have improved significantly...most commercial flour is refined and clump-free, meaning there's no real need to sift it."
  2. Weighing is the new "measuring" method for bread (for my American readers). If you want to be more than a one-trick pony when it comes to baking bread, a digital scale is essential.

🤔 It just occurred to me that bread machines are often sold with measuring cups. What a mistake! If I sold those machines, I would include a free digital scale. I bet there wouldn't be near as many bread machines in garage sales. (I would also remove the "bake" button, but that's a topic for another day.)

One caveat: If you happen to purchase a bag of flour with lumps, go ahead and sift it (place a big sifter over a big bowl and stir with a whisk until all the flour goes into the bowl.) You still need to weigh it when you make bread, but it will mix easier when added to your bread machine.

Find links to my favorite digital scales in my Amazon Store. Unfortunately, I can't make it link through email, so type Amazon Store SaladinaJar into the search box.

See this post if you have more questions about measuring flour for bread,​


If you want to practice weighing flour, try my recipe for Easy Enough Bread Machine Pretzel Dough for Buns or Rolls.

What readers say about Bread Machine Pretzel Buns:

Saying good-bye to my rusty old sifter,

Paula

p.s Thank you for sharing this email and recipe with your favorite bread-baking friends.

Salad in a Jar

Check out my previous newsletters below. If you haven't already, sign up for my newsletter!

Read more from Salad in a Jar
bread machine versus stand mixer for yeast bread

WELCOME BREAD MACHINES YOGURT SALAD IN A JAR RECIPE INDEX If you already own a bread machine, you may have wondered whether your stand mixer could do the same job. I use both, but for a single batch of bread dough, there’s one part of the process that keeps me reaching for the bread machine. See how the two compare—and why I usually stop my bread machine before it bakes anything. Comparing a bread machine and a stand mixer for making yeast bread Here is a special pumpkin bread recipe for you...

pizza made with bread machine pizza dough sliced and ready to eat

WELCOME BREAD MACHINES YOGURT SALAD IN A JAR RECIPE INDEX My creativity in the kitchen has gone into hiding during the high temperatures of the past few weeks. I’m hoping it comes back soon. Does that ever happen to you when it’s time to cook dinner? True confession: I’ve also been distracted by Mahjong this summer. My husband, children, grandchildren, and I have all learned to play, and we’re having a wonderful time with it. I’ve made new friends and gotten to know my neighbors better. I may...

Sliced white bread in a basket with butter on the side

WELCOME BREAD MACHINES YOGURT SALAD IN A JAR RECIPE INDEX It's hard to get in the mood to bake bread when the temperatures climb. On the other hand, if you're lucky enough to have fresh tomatoes, homemade bread takes a BLT to another level. So I keep baking—usually by turning the oven on early in the morning. While testing a new-to-me recipe yesterday, I ran into something I don't think I've ever talked about. The recipe was written in metric measurements (thankfully), but it also listed tiny...