Will my bread be better if I increase the yeast?


Have you ever wondered if adding more yeast would improve the texture of your bread?

Unfortunately, more yeast may help your bread rise faster (which is not good) but will not make your bread lighter in texture.

Question #1: What does it hurt if my bread rises faster?

1. The faster yeast dough rises, the quicker it produces waste products like CO2 and alcohol. Because alcohol is naturally acidic, it can weaken the gluten structure causing the dough to rise too fast and fall before it bakes through. Sometimes, too much yeast has the opposite effect and the dough barely rises.

2. The faster yeast dough rises, the less time the dough has to develop the complex yeast flavors we associate with an amazing homemade or artisan loaf. A faulty rise (too much or too little) can also cause yeasty flavors.

Have you ever noticed how dinner rolls or loaves of bread that didn't rise properly taste yeasty? Especially when they are cold? I'm reminded of my favorite saying around here:

Even bad bread tastes good when it's warm. Don't be fooled.

Question #2: Sometimes, my dough is barely rising. My company is on the way. Help!

Answer: Move the dough to a warmer location but no more than 85˚F (29˚C). High proofing temperatures have the same effect as too much yeast.

SUMMARY:

Manage the speed of the rise by increasing or decreasing the temperature of the dough. It's OK to decrease the yeast to slow the rise if you have time, but it's not good to increase the yeast.

Disclaimer: If you use your bread machine to mix, knead, and bake your bread, these suggestions do not apply. You're stuck with the computer setup of your machine. Consider using the DOUGH cycle and baking in your oven so you can take control and make fabulous bread you'll be excited to share.



One of my readers recently asked for a recipe for Cuban Bread or Pan Cubano. She needed a recipe she could mix in a bread machine since the store where she buys it is a long drive from her home. Request granted!

Cuban bread is similar to my popular French bread recipe. It has a soft crumb (use all-purpose flour if you want) and a slightly sweet taste with a moderately crisp crust that softens eventually. In addition to making Cuban sandwiches, the flatter shape (sliced in half horizontally) makes it perfect for garlic toast, paninis, or dipping in thick soups like gumbo or beef stew.

If you make this bread, please invite me over to watch "I Love Lucy" while it rises. The candy factory episode is my favorite.

Paula

Salad in a Jar

Check out my previous newsletters below. If you haven't already, sign up for my newsletter!

Read more from Salad in a Jar
Easy bread machine cinnamon roll, frosted and ready to serve.

No matter where you are on your bread-making journey, I’ve got a Christmas-morning-worthy recipe for you — whether you’re baking for brunch, snacks, or something sweet to nibble while the coffee brews. Beginning Bread Bakers Start Here: Easy Bread Machine Cinnamon Rolls with a Secret Ingredients A great make-ahead option for beginners. Mix the dough the day before and bake in the morning. The secret? A tiny pinch of cloves (optional) that adds warmth without shouting. Click to see the recipe...

slice and bake coconut shortbread

Hi Friends, My mom was ahead of her time when she engaged in a little DIY aversion therapy with my pre-teen self. One day, I asked if I could make a full batch of Butterscotch Refrigerator Cookies purely to eat the dough. After a moment of hesitation, she said, “Go right ahead.” So I did… and I ate most of it right on the spot. Not surprisingly, I never made that recipe again. These days I stick to cookies I actually enjoy baked—one at a time, mostly 😉—like my Slice and Bake Coconut...

dough rising out of the bread machine pan

Hi Friends, If you’re planning to make rolls this Thanksgiving, especially from an old family recipe, here’s a quick PSA before the flour starts flying. Many of those heirloom recipes are long on love and tradition but short on modern measurements—and definitely not written with bread machines in mind. Don’t let that stop you. Just keep these two things in mind as you adapt them. 1) Watch the flour amount. Most bread machines (except 3-lb machines) can't handle more than 4-4½ cups of flour....