Three Slice-and-Bake Cookies to Keep on Standby


Hi Friends,

My mom was ahead of her time when she engaged in a little DIY aversion therapy with my pre-teen self. One day, I asked if I could make a full batch of Butterscotch Refrigerator Cookies purely to eat the dough. After a moment of hesitation, she said, “Go right ahead.”

So I did… and I ate most of it right on the spot.

Not surprisingly, I never made that recipe again.

These days I stick to cookies I actually enjoy baked—one at a time, mostly 😉—like my Slice and Bake Coconut Shortbread Cookies or my Chocolate Icebox Cookies with Oatmeal.

I’ll confess, the dough still calls my name from the freezer, especially right before dinner when I’m digging around looking for frozen onions. But what I love most is having something sweet ready to bake or share at a moment’s notice.

And for those of you with air fryers or toaster ovens, these slice-and-bake beauties are perfect. Cut off exactly as many as you want and bake them in a countertop oven that preheats in a snap.

Here are three of my favorite slice-and-bake cookie recipes:

Slice-and-Bake Coconut Shortbread Cookies

Only five ingredients (butter, sugar, vanilla, flour, and coconut) and zero eggs.

— ✧ — ✧ —

Double Chocolate Icebox Cookies (Slice-and-Bake with Oatmeal)

I know it looks like coconut in the picture, but it's oatmeal. That makes these cookies healthy, right? 😉

— ✧ — ✧ —

Peanut Butter Pinwheel Cookies with Melted Chocolate Swirl

These vintage cookies wrap melted chocolate inside a peanut butter dough. Slicing can be a bit tricky (dough has to be the right temperature) but you absolutely can do it.

— ✧ — ✧ —

Shared and Loved

"Your Slice-and-Bake Coconut Shortbread Cookies were delicious and foolproof! My new favorite cookie." – BAILEY

From my freezer stash to yours,

Paula Rhodes | Home Economist

P.S. The PA in our family says it's not safe to eat raw cookie dough. Guess I've been lucky all these years. Consider yourself forewarned.

You are receiving this email because you signed up for emails on the Salad in a Jar website.
Unsubscribe | Update Your Interests | 4621 S. Cooper Ste 119, Arlington, TX 76017

Salad in a Jar

Check out my previous newsletters below. If you haven't already, sign up for my newsletter!

Read more from Salad in a Jar
dough rising out of the bread machine pan

Hi Friends, If you’re planning to make rolls this Thanksgiving, especially from an old family recipe, here’s a quick PSA before the flour starts flying. Many of those heirloom recipes are long on love and tradition but short on modern measurements—and definitely not written with bread machines in mind. Don’t let that stop you. Just keep these two things in mind as you adapt them. 1) Watch the flour amount. Most bread machines (except 3-lb machines) can't handle more than 4-4½ cups of flour....

Bread Machine Pita Bread and Pockets

Have you ever tasted something fresh for the first time and wondered why you spent years settling for the packaged version? That was me the day I walked into a Middle Eastern grocery store and bought a bag of warm pita bread. The package was still steamy, and I suddenly understood what pita was supposed to be. Store-bought pita can’t hold a candle to the homemade kind. My brand-new recipe for Bread Machine Pita Bread (with an optional oatmeal twist!) is finally live. Your bread machine...

homemade cream of mushroom soup substitute

Whether you are making a gift list for yourself or someone else, here are two things I think every baker or cook should have and use in their kitchen. DIGITAL SCALE: The fastest way to cook and bake more consistently—especially with flour. Weighing in grams removes guesswork and keeps recipes repeatable. Look for a scale with a tare button, 1-gram (or 0.1-oz) resolution, and an easy-to-read display. Set your mixing bowl on the scale and start dumping--no measuring cups required. I like the...