Why Your Bake Didn't Turn Out


I know how frustrating baking mishaps can be!

Right before Christmas, one of the electronic boards in my oven went out. I don’t fully understand the mechanics, but it was still heating—just not enough. After buying a thermometer to test it, I called my repairman, but not before I ended up with a large sourdough bread order that refused to rise and brown properly. Talk about embarrassing!

Here are some common reasons things might go wrong with your baking project (includes making yogurt, bread, or candy):

Ingredients weren’t weighed

  • Measuring by volume can be inaccurate.
  • A kitchen scale ensures consistency.

Wrong bakeware

  • Glass pans retain more heat than metal leading to uneven baking (also applies to Corning Ware).
  • Lightweight, inexpensive metal pans can cause uneven browning and make sticking worse

Oven temperature off

  • Many ovens run hotter or cooler than set.
  • Use an oven thermometer to check.

Substitutions gone wrong

  • Some swaps affect texture and structure.
  • Not all ingredients can be replaced 1:1.
  • If it's a dietary issue, consider looking for a different recipe.

Watching the clock instead of the food

  • Different brands and ingredient origins can affect the outcome.
  • Temperature and humidity are just a couple of factors that can impact a recipe.

Baking is part science, part art—every attempt teaches something new. Let me know if you need help troubleshooting! Pictures are always appreciated.

Happy Bakers Speak Up

A reader sent me a letter that truly made my day (seen below). I’m sharing it to remind you why I believe it's worth the time and trouble to create food worth sharing.

"My 'old' bread machine was tucked away collecting dust until I discovered your site. Now I make homemade bread at least weekly & it has become an enjoyable hobby!!! Your rye bread recipe has become a favorite & I have one rising right now, which I will take as a gift to the host who has invited us for dinner."
Donna K.

Happy Baking,

Paula

You are receiving this email because you signed up for emails on the Salad in a Jar website.
Unsubscribe | Update Your Interests | 4621 S. Cooper Ste 119, Arlington, TX 76017

Salad in a Jar

Check out my previous newsletters below. If you haven't already, sign up for my newsletter!

Read more from Salad in a Jar
sliced sourdough loaf

You've just pulled a beautiful loaf from the oven—golden crust, warm, with an aroma that's driving you crazy. The temptation to slice it right now is real. But if you want the best texture and flavor, give it time to cool. Here’s why patience matters: – Avoid gummy texture: Cutting too soon traps steam before the crumb finishes setting. – Avoid squishing your loaf: Warm bread is delicate and can compress under the pressure of a knife. For delicate breads like babka, this can be disastrous. –...

loaf cooked in a too-small pan next to loaf cooked in a bigger pan

Ever mixed up a beautiful batch of bread machine dough only to have it bake up too short...or overflow the pan? 🤦🏼♀️ Picking the right pan makes all the difference! I'm sure the above loaves tasted equally good, but which one would you rather share? In my latest post, I break down exactly which loaf pans work best based on your dough weight, plus a few tricks for improvising when you don’t have the perfect size on hand. 🔹 The Golden Rule for choosing a pan 🔹 Exceptions for whole-grain and...

baked whole wheat rolls on a cutting board

Should you add Vital Wheat Gluten or dough conditioners to your bread recipes? Let’s break it down! Vital Wheat Gluten and dough conditioners both improve dough performance, but they do it differently. Is it worth the money? You decide. Vital Wheat Gluten 🔹 What it does: Strengthens gluten, helping low-gluten and whole grain doughs rise better.🔹 What it’s made of: Nearly pure wheat protein.🔹 How to use it: Add 1–2 tablespoons per loaf to boost elasticity and structure. Dough Conditioner 🔹...