Want Better Bread? Try This 10-Second Dough Test


Have you heard of the "windowpane" test? It may help you make better bread?

It’s not about house windows — it’s a simple way to check gluten development in your dough.


How to Do It
Take a small piece of dough and gently stretch it with your fingers.

  • If it thins enough to let light through before tearing, the gluten is fully developed.
  • If it tears, don’t panic — what you do next depends on your dough and timing.

What to Do If Your Dough Fails the Test

  • If your dough will be resting for hours (like sourdough) or overnight: Time will do the work. Gluten keeps developing as it rests, so there’s no need to knead again.
  • If you’re shaping the dough immediately after the first rise: The dough should be smooth and stretchy by the end of the DOUGH cycle. If it’s not, run the cycle for a few extra minutes.
  • If the dough just won’t stretch: Check the hydration. Too dry? Add a teaspoon of water and knead it in. Too wet? Add a sprinkle of flour until it sticks briefly, then pulls away cleanly from the bowl.

When to Use the Windowpane

  • Trying different flours: Brands, types, and even seasons can change how your dough behaves.
  • Swapping in whole wheat: Extra kneading may be helpful. With 100% whole grain doughs, you may even need to repeat the kneading phase for a few minutes.
  • Adapting recipes: Hand, stand-mixer, and bread machine kneading can differ, so times listed in recipes don’t always translate. The windowpane test can help.
  • Sourdough: Many bakers use this test during bulk rise as one of several readiness clues.

I can’t cover every nuance of gluten development here — my goal is to introduce the concept and help you start applying it in your bread-making journey.

Do you use this test? Hit reply and tell me when you find it most helpful.

Happy Bread Baking,

Paula

Home Economist / Food Worth Sharing

You are receiving this email because you signed up for emails on the Salad in a Jar website.
Unsubscribe | Update Your Interests | 4621 S. Cooper Ste 119, Arlington, TX 76017

Salad in a Jar

Check out my previous newsletters below. If you haven't already, sign up for my newsletter!

Read more from Salad in a Jar
Sliced dried fruit bread on a cutting board-- one piece slathered with blackberry jelly.

Hi Friends, If you’re shopping for a bread machine—or wondering why your pan looks worn—here’s a quick behind-the-scenes look at something most manufacturers never talk about: the nonstick coating. ⭐ Almost All Bread Machine Pans Are Coated Whether it’s called PTFE, Teflon, or “nonstick,” nearly every bread machine pan uses a slick coating so the paddles can knead without the dough grabbing onto the sides. Uncoated pans simply don’t release well enough for bread dough. ⭐ Is It Safe? Bread...

Slow cooker queso dip poured over Frito chips with salsa on the side

Do you have a Super Bowl tradition? We usually gather with a small circle of longtime friends, our married kids, and a few of their in-laws who live nearby. Nothing fancy—just football, lots of conversation, and a table full of food everyone looks forward to. This year, I’m bringing the queso dip and the candied pecans you see below, but any of these recipes would fit right in at a Super Bowl spread. If you’re still deciding what to make, I hope this gives you a few dependable ideas. All of...

buttermilk loaf with a flyaway top

Hi Friends, As promised, this is the follow-up to the email I sent a couple of weeks ago. Previously, we talked about why a loaf of bread collapses inward on the sides after it’s baked and removed from the pan. You can read it here. Today, I’m exploring why the top of a home-baked loaf of bread lifts off—sometimes evenly, but more often just on one side, and sometimes quite dramatically. 1. The crust set too early.If the outside firms up before the inside finishes expanding, trapped steam and...